I can’t make up my mind whether I like this book or not.
While I was reading it I alternated between wondering why I’m still reading and it and going ” oh! wow! intriguing!”
I guess what counts that, as a person who will stop reading a book I don’t like, is that I COULD NOT stop reading and had to see how it ended.
The book made me think of a modern, unorthodox Mary Poppins story, without any of the British “proper” behavior of Mary Poppins!
I had heard that this book was engaging , thought provoking and even amusing.
Therefore I delayed reading it till the trip to Alaksa.
Four people (two young adults /teenagers ) on the road together for three weeks – nothing like adding some unusual topics to discuss along the way! The chapter “Do parents really matter?” really caught everyone’s attention (it includes the question “Does it matter if parents read aloud to their kids or not!!!! Boy, have I read aloud!!!) . The chapter about the reduction of violence in the USA during the 1990’s was also fascinating!
Even if you aren’t going on the road for three weeks – it IS an engaging, thought provoking and amusing book! Glad I read it!
I haven’t updated this category since we left for Alaska but I have been reading!
This was the first book that I read on the trip. I had seen the movie years ago and didn’t remember too much about it except that I really enjoyed it.
Perfect choice for many hours of traveling – light, engaging, interesting and amusing.
Not long ago I asked for recommendations for a useful book that my aunt in the U.S could send me for my birthday. By the way, the recommendations are here if you want to see them or add one of your own!
I’m glad I chose this book! I got a warm recommendation for this book. Although I duly noted that info I’m embarrassed to say that I did not note who recommended it – so if you are reading this post this THANK YOU is for you!
What I will do with ideas from the book in class is not a topic for a Saturday’s posting, but the book isn’t just for teachers. It is a book that enriches your knowledge of visual information. There are some photography tips too, we’ll see if I remember them when taking pictures in Alaska!
I can’t resist sharing with you a lovely idea in the book. I was just flipping through the book and it was the first thing I read:
Page 184, activity 363 Gift Catalogue:
Have students make a list of things that can be enjoyed for free. Photograph those things and place them in a “priceless” catalogue.
Besides all the various material I’m reading, you can now find me “armed” with an MP3 player (never had one before), moving around the house and listening to Mark Twain!
Did you know it can be legally downloaded for free from Libravox?
Although I was more interested in Mark Twan’s book “The Innocents Abroad” as it was about Europe and the Middle East, his delightful language and descriptions are such a pleasure to listen to that even silver mines become interesting!
Now I can get more reading done this summer, by reading and listening!
I’m very conflicted about this book.
Lionel Shriver’s writing is brilliant. She (Yes, Lionel is a woman’s name! I was surprised!) draws the reader in and captivates with truly impressive prose.
Obviously she’s trying to shock and provoke the reader. Somewhat like a well written version of a Michael Moore film. There are certainly points to think about regarding society, media, parenting and more.
On the other hand, I felt that the author undermines her own message by depicting SUCH a dysfunctional family. It’s hard to buy the message that it isn’t just the parent’s fault with these parents, particulary the father and the relationship between the parents. I kept screaming at them ( in my head) throughout the whole book, from the beginning almost: “why aren’t you all in therapy?!!
Also, the ending -sigh. I watch a lot of foreign films (foreign, as in not Hollywood) and well, without spoiling it for anybody, that was an American ending. A movie which I actually hated (gave me nightmares!), but deals with comparable topics and has an ending which is more believable is Funny Games by Michael Haneke (the original version, don’t know anything about the American Remake). Though I’m not actually recommending you watch the movie… there are others that are more palatable. Just here the topic is similar.
I’m also somewhat concerned – many of the people who recommended this book to me aren’t parents yet. I do hope this book hasn’t scared them!
My next book will be something more cheerful!
The recommendations to read this book were very strong and kind of “creepy”:
* A “must” read – it will rock your world.
* Steel yourself but hang in there until the powerful conclusion.
* Don’t plan to be doing much else while you read it as you won’t be able to stop
To top it off the librarian said (when I checked out the book)
“I couldn’t read anything else for a week after that, I was so shaken”.
A bit scary!
I’ve just read chapter one so far and am hooked (though still not enough to have trouble stopping, yet). Will save commnets for next Saturday’s post – too early to talk about it!
I’m reading this as a sequel to “Stones from the River” by the same author. This tells about the post WW2 years in the same small village in Germany.
Turns out, though, that it isn’t a sequel. It was written before the other book and served as the inspiration for it.
I think the other is better and should be read first.
This one is good too.
Thirteen delightful ways to look at the number 13!
One of those books that “hook you'” from the word “go”!
So far (I’m up to page 100) it’s on my “highly recommend” list!