“What ARE you talking about?” VS. Lizzie Pinnard’s Post

June marks a year and a half that I have been fascinated by the “World of English Teachers on Blogosphere”. It IS just like having a world of professional development at your fingertips. At least that is the way I feel. But is this “world” as inviting to all English teachers (who are comfortable using the Internet that is) as it is to me?

Coming from the standpoint of a teacher in the national school system (of whom there are precious few on twittersphere compared to teachers in language schools) I find there are four kinds of posts:

1)      Being a Teacher:

Photo by Gil Epshtein

Posts such as Steven Herder’s “How Important is Lesson Planning“? His discussion of Spontaneous Learning Opportunities Windows is one that an English teacher, or even anyone interested in teaching regardless of the subject, can easily relate to. The specifics of the setting really don’t matter. In fact, I find that iTDi Blog seems to have a lot of posts that fit this category.

2)      Classroom Strategies:

Posts that offer wonderful ideas to use in class. Take Mike Harrison’s post on “Reverse Reading Comprehension” as an example. I’ve found my colleagues here to be very interested in this strategy, once we got past the obstacle of SIZE OF CLASS! My boys went through the entire school system here in classes of 32 to 40 students. There are many who write off such posts right away and claim there is no point in reading foreign material as they have no idea of our reality. I believe that I never had a problem ignoring the size of the class described because I have never had any expectations that I would find anything tailored to my needs  – “The adapter” is my second name!

3)      “What ARE you talking about?” Posts:

Photo by Gil Epshtein

There are some posts which are simply baffling. Jemma Gardner has a wonderful blog which I follow enthusiastically. But her post Each to Their Own  serves as an example of this. I still can’t quite figure out the teacher training process she is referring to, as I’m only familiar with three to four year training programs, which include a degree and practical experience in the class as a student teacher. I think I’ve picked up a pretty good idea of what the difference is between a Celta and a Delta and I have heard so much about the textbook Global that I’m beginning to be able to picture it. As I personally follow Jemma’s posts regularly I’m able to deal with not understanding everything because those things aren’t the point she is making, which IS very clear and relevant!

4)      The Posts that Don’t Exist:

Photo by Gil Epshtein

As a teacher in the national school system there are some topics that simply are not being discussed. For example, high-school teachers who know they have 4 / 5 hours a week to prepare their students for the national exams in May. Then the school proceeds to cancel lessons right and left (lectures on the dangers of smoking, alcohol, lectures on finance, ceremonies, class trips, extra lessons needed for MATH, etc.) Yet the students must be ready in time. How does one perform this miracle? And what about the time spent recording texts for learning disabled students or testing them orally during your own breaks? These don’t seem to be issues in language schools.


However, then you read Lizzie Pinard’s inspiring post “The Journey of a Thousand Miles and you realize there is only one thing to say to other teachers:

Photo by Gil Epshtein

Despite the differences, ignoring what is being offered to you in the great world out there is like sticking your head in the sand.

10 thoughts on ““What ARE you talking about?” VS. Lizzie Pinnard’s Post”

  1. Hi Naomi,

    Just a quick one- I work with Jemma Gardner and we both train teachers on the Trinity CertTESOL programme: http://www.trinitycollege.co.uk/site/?id=201

    It’s very similar to the CELTA (run by Cambridge ESOL), which Jemma is also a trainer for – both courses are typically 4 weeks long, all day, every day, with input sessions and teaching practice during the week and assignments to write during the weekends. I currently train on this (4-week) course and Jemma’s training on the part-time version which our school also runs (13 weeks but still very intensive for trainees and tutors alike!). I’m not very familiar with your teaching context, but having certified on one of these courses is generally the basic, standard, minimum requirement for TEFL in private language schools all over the world – or at least, definitely across Europe.

    (Just to try and help clear up some of that confusion you mentioned!) 🙂


  2. Laura!
    So nice of you to take the time to write. I really appreciate. Jemma also said she would be explaining things!
    Specifically what I didn’t understand in what way the trainees could be on different levels – different level of teaching abilities? of English?
    But the general problem is that I’m trying to imagine a four year degree needed here to become a qualified English teacher with a teacher’s license condensed into 4 weeks…
    Thanks so much!

  3. Hi Naomi,
    This is a great summary of the kind of posts we read. I’m going to save it and use it in future blog training sessions. I hope we can start to get more people in category four blogging, because I agree that it is a hole which needs filling.

  4. Ones where I introduce others to the world of blogging 🙂
    And I think the two-level thing is about classes – during the course you have to teach groups of students at two different levels, normally pre-intermediate and upper intermediate. I agree that it doesn’t seem like much compared to a full degree, which is why I don’t understand why non-natives with a teaching degree are sometimes ovrlooked in favour of natives with a CELTA. It does mean it’s a steep learning curve afterwards!

    1. You certainly write beautifully with a lot of relevant issues for all teachers. Best of all I know I can always ask you to expalin the sometiimes mystifying world of language schools!
      Great blog!

  5. Great categorisation of blogosphere posts, Naomi. =D Why don’t you move the “posts that don’t exist” category into ones that do with your own posts? 😉

    1. Afraid I can’t do that, Tyson!
      As you know I fill my blog with the things I can write about. The examples I mentioned are those often discussed on our Israeli teacher’s list and heard in the staff room. These are the teachers with the 40 kids and less wiggle room than I have. In special ed sometimes kids stay another year if they couldn’t keep up, just to mention one difference. They can stay till their 21 !

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *